Sometimes an idea is too ridiculous to avoid. That’s the case with The Great Muppet Casting Call, in which we cast celebrities as the Muppets for each of their feature films. But since the Muppets appear as themselves in their movies over and over again, we needed to swap out the criteria for our casting choices over and over again. And we just couldn’t resist the temptation to make those criteria more and more bizarre as they went on.
The Muppet Movie
A-list celebrities as the Muppets
The Great Muppet Caper
Gender-bent comedic actors as the Muppets
Muppets Take Manhattan
1980s stars as the Muppets
Follow That Bird
Silent movie stars as the Muppets
Muppet Christmas Carol
The cast of The Great British Bake-Off as the Muppets
Muppet Treasure Island
Robin Williams characters as the Muppets
Muppets From Space
The Golden Girls as as the Muppets
Elmo in Grouchland
Disney’s Gargoyles as the Muppets
The Muppets
Obscure DC Comics characters as the Muppets
Muppets Most Wanted
“Now That’s What I Call Music!” albums as the Muppets
